Cutler Bay
South Miami-Dade

Cutler Bay

Cutler Bay, Florida

Growing community offering affordable waterfront living near Biscayne National Park.

$300K - $2M+

Price Range

0

Active Listings

Cutler Bay

City

33157, 33189, 33190

ZIP Code(s)

Lifestyle

Affordable, outdoor recreation, family-friendly

Communities

83

Cutler Cay

16 listings

$840K – $2.2M

Lakes By The Bay Sec 5

6 listings

$500K – $539K

Whispering Pines Estates

5 listings

$780K – $3.3M

Lakes By The Bay Gee

5 listings

$430K – $580K

The Courts At Bayshore I

5 listings

$305K – $400K

The Courts At Bayshore Ii

5 listings

$280K – $340K

Bel-aire Sec 1

4 listings

$669K – $850K

Whispering Pines Est Sec

4 listings

$569K – $849K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 6

4 listings

$465K – $600K

Santa Barbara

4 listings

$390K – $475K

Omni Estates 2nd Addn

3 listings

$1.2M – $1.6M

Cutler Cay,cutler Cay

3 listings

$1.1M – $1.3M

Capistrano

3 listings

$950K – $1.0M

Lakes By The Bay Sec 7

3 listings

$600K – $1M

Cutler Ridge Sec 5

3 listings

$580K – $805K

Cutler Ridge Sec 4

3 listings

$624K – $750K

Pelican Bay At Old Cutler

3 listings

$620K – $699K

Bel Aire Sec 3

3 listings

$620K – $675K

S Coral Homes Sec 3

3 listings

$594K – $660K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 8

3 listings

$499K – $550K

Enclave South Phase 2

3 listings

$414K – $430K

Saga Bay Townhomes

3 listings

$397K – $420K

Lakes By The Bay Eve Repl

3 listings

$385K – $400K

Perrine Grant Sub

2 listings

$2.6M

Lincoln City Sec G

2 listings

$370K – $1,000K

Saga Bay Sec 1 Pt 4

2 listings

$650K – $990K

Saga Bay Sec One Part Two,saga Bay

2 listings

$825K – $932K

Tenalla Ocean Farms

2 listings

$749K – $822K

Bel Aire Sec 15

2 listings

$760K – $765K

Herfa Sub

2 listings

$680K – $735K

Cutler Ridge Pines

2 listings

$665K – $720K

Bel-aire Sec 2

2 listings

$665K – $699K

Cutler Ridge Sec 3

2 listings

$595K – $660K

South Coral Homes Sec 2

2 listings

$575K – $639K

Lakes By The Bay Faye Rep

2 listings

$600K – $635K

Lakes By The Bay Day

2 listings

$569K – $590K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 12

2 listings

$525K – $575K

Lakes By The Bay Cee

2 listings

$417K – $465K

Perrine Industrial Park

1 listing

$3M

Cutler Country Groves 1st

1 listing

$2.5M

Costa Brava

1 listing

$1.7M

Old Cutler Estates

1 listing

$1.5M

Old Cutler Grove

1 listing

$995K

Rosewood Homes

1 listing

$995K

Century At Cutler Bay

1 listing

$994K

Cutler Ridge Sec 6

1 listing

$880K

Bel-aire Sec 23

1 listing

$879K

Whispering Pines Estates,whispering Pines

1 listing

$860K

Bel Aire

1 listing

$799K

Pelican Bay At Old Cutler,pelican Bay At Old C

1 listing

$775K

Lakes By The Bay Amber

1 listing

$740K

Enclave At Black Point Ma,enclave

1 listing

$730K

Old Cutler Cove

1 listing

$725K

Pelican Bay At Old Cutler

1 listing

$708K

Saga Bay Sec 1 Pt 7

1 listing

$700K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 4

1 listing

$700K

Bel Aire Sec 6

1 listing

$698K

Cutler Ridge Sec 3,cutler Ridge

1 listing

$679K

Bel Aire Sec 3,bel Aire

1 listing

$660K

Whispering Pines Est Sec,whispering Pines

1 listing

$650K

So Miami Heights Addn N

1 listing

$645K

Cutler Bay

1 listing

$630K

Lakes By The Bay Kaye,isles At Bayshore

1 listing

$630K

Enclave At Black Point Ma

1 listing

$630K

Centennial Sec 2

1 listing

$600K

Aurora Park Sub

1 listing

$590K

Precious Homes At Lakes B,lakes By The Bay

1 listing

$585K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 3

1 listing

$575K

Enclave At Black Point Ma,enclave At Black Poi

1 listing

$565K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 6,catalina West

1 listing

$550K

The Ridges Amend

1 listing

$490K

Lakes By The Bay Gee,isles At Bayshore

1 listing

$458K

Old Cutler Cove Addn

1 listing

$450K

Santa Barbara 1st Addn

1 listing

$425K

Lakes By The Bay Eve Repl,the Shores

1 listing

$400K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 9 Am

1 listing

$389K

Point Royale Buildings On

1 listing

$379K

Black Creek Villas

1 listing

$375K

Point Royale Bldgs 3 & 4

1 listing

$360K

Lakes By The Bay Sec 9 Am,lakes By The Bay

1 listing

$330K

Royale Point-townvillas C

1 listing

$326K

Le Club At Old Cutler Con,le Club At Old Cutle

1 listing

$296K

Le Club At Old Cutler Con

1 listing

$290K

Market Statistics

Active listings & sold data from the past 12 months

Homes

Active Listings (215)

Avg. List Price $622,322
Median List Price $569,000
Avg. Price / Sq Ft $336
Avg. Living Area 1,798 sqft
Avg. Lot Size 9,389 sqft

Sold — Past 12 Months (484)

Avg. Sold Price $581,994
Median Sold Price $565,000
Avg. Sold Price / Sq Ft $345
Avg. Original List Price $597,509
Avg. Living Area 1,740 sqft
Avg. Lot Size 8,353 sqft

Get Monthly Market Updates

Receive a personalized Cutler Bay market report every month — including price trends, new listings, recent sales, and price-per-square-foot analysis.

  • Active & sold comps by property type
  • Price / sq ft trends over time
  • Off-market opportunities in this area

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Recent Sales

Last 10 properties sold in Cutler Bay

Address Sold Price List Price Close Date Type Beds Baths Sq Ft $/Sq Ft Lot Size SP/LP % DOM
19339 SW 80th Ct, Cutler Bay FL 33157 $1,850,000 $2,000,000 Apr 14, 2026 Home 5 5 4,612 $401 17,598 sf 92.5% 57
8560 SW 214th Way, Cutler Bay FL 33189 $399,000 $399,000 Apr 10, 2026 Home 3 3 1,504 $265 100.0% 5
10120 Nicaragua Dr, Cutler Bay FL 33189 $670,000 $699,000 Apr 10, 2026 Home 4 2 1,800 $372 8,923 sf 95.9% 232
9775 SW 221st St, Cutler Bay FL 33190 $498,000 $510,000 Apr 10, 2026 Home 3 2 1,369 $364 3,506 sf 97.6% 97
9380 Caribbean Blvd, Cutler Bay FL 33189 $655,000 $654,995 Apr 9, 2026 Home 5 2 1,972 $332 7,669 sf 100.0% 111
19831 Gulfstream Rd, Cutler Bay FL 33157 $695,000 $699,000 Apr 9, 2026 Home 4 3 1,331 $522 7,700 sf 99.4% 45
10321 SW 232nd St, Cutler Bay FL 33190 $739,000 $739,000 Apr 8, 2026 Home 5 3 3,363 $220 8,363 sf 100.0% 23
8875 SW 223rd Ln, Cutler Bay FL 33190 $410,000 $434,999 Apr 8, 2026 Home 3 3 1,617 $254 94.3% 278
21102 SW 92nd Ct, Cutler Bay FL 33189 $649,899 $649,899 Apr 6, 2026 Home 3 2 1,728 $376 5,000 sf 100.0% 6
19341 Holiday Rd, Cutler Bay FL 33157 $665,000 $665,000 Apr 6, 2026 Home 4 3 2,133 $312 11,550 sf 100.0% 108

Properties in Cutler Bay

View All →

No active listings

Check back soon for new properties in Cutler Bay.

Nearby Neighborhoods